The Right to Repair is in the Center of the National Stage

The Right to Repair is in the Center of the National Stage

As vehicle technology increases, access to these systems and their data has become critical to the vehicle service process.

Right to Repair is the issue involving the aftermarket industry’s long battle with global vehicle manufacturers over the access to the vehicle data necessary for repair and maintenance. As vehicles have become more laden with computer-controlled sensors and technology, the ability to access these systems and the data they generate has become critical to the vehicle service process. In the past decade, the wireless transmission of this telematics data has changed the game further. Today, 50% of vehicles in the U.S. are equipped with wireless telematics. By 2030, 95% of all vehicles sold in the U.S. will be so equipped.

The problem is one of access to this telematics data. Most consumers have no idea their vehicle is beaming information about miles driven, speed, acceleration, sudden stopping and destinations to the vehicle manufacturers and other parties. 

The data about vehicle performance has value in predicting component failure and maintenance requirements – but, only if you have access to it. And there is the heart of the matter. Wireless telematics-data transmission was built into the vehicle to serve the interests of the vehicle manufacturers and their service network. There is currently no system in place to allow access to this data by the vehicle owner or independent service providers of their choosing.

The current state of vehicle telematics data is a closed and proprietary system under the control of the manufacturers that limits consumer choice in where some repairs and service can be performed. As wireless-data transmission becomes more ubiquitous, the consumer’s right to choose is severely restricted, resulting in paying higher costs and less competition. Right to Repair is about securing the vehicle owner’s right to choose where they get their vehicle serviced. Since 70% of post-warranty vehicle service work is performed in the independent aftermarket, our industry has a lot to lose if freedom of choice is taken away. And, the vehicle manufacturers have a lot to gain in monetizing predictive analytics and marketing their products and services based on the actual odometer reading and component conditions on a vehicle.

As vehicles have become more laden with computer-controlled sensors and technology, the ability to access these systems and the data they generate has become critical to the vehicle service process.

Fortunately, our national trade associations have aligned to educate the industry, consumers and legislators about this issue and the need for Right to Repair legislation. Millions of dollars and many years of effort were culminated in November 2020, when the Massachusetts Right to Repair ballot initiative was approved by 75% of the voters. This victory was secured despite a fierce campaign by the auto manufacturers to paint R2R as an anti-privacy initiative and some industry effort to steal the personal information of car-owners. The voters of Massachusetts weren’t fooled, and the ballot measure requiring service-data access by the 2022 model year passed, requiring:

• Notification and explanation of the purpose and data types created by the vehicle and the owner’s ability to manage access

• Vehicles to be equipped with an open and secure platform to access the data

• Standardized data access to be available without vehicle manufacturer authorization

In November of 2020, not long after the ballot initiative was approved by voters, the automakers sued to overturn the legislation, challenging it as unconstitutional and impractical to implement. A ruling in the case has been delayed on multiple occasions and is currently expected in March 2022. In a February hearing on the case, it was learned that two automakers, Kia and Subaru, had chosen to disable the telematic capabilities of their 2022 vehicles sold in Massachusetts. Rather than sell vehicle that were out of compliance with telematics requirements, they simply turned off their entire telematics system, which included other features such as roadside assistance and crash notification. The fact that attorneys for the vehicle manufacturers did not inform the court of the actions taken by Kia and Subaru did not please the court. The judgment expected soon will either uphold the Right to Repair legislation, overturn the ballot initiative approved by 75% of the vote or prescribe legislation to remedy the matter.

The fact is that a technical solution to securely authorize access to vehicle telematics data does exist and is ready to deploy. The major trade associations in the U.S. worked with their European counterparts under the auspices of the International Organization for Standards (ISO) to develop three ISO Standards for the Secure Vehicle Interface (SVI): Standards TS21177, TS21184 and TS21185. A working prototype of SVI was demonstrated at Joe’s Garage at AAPEX 2021.

To the credit of all the organizations and dedicated individuals who have had a role in the Right to Repair battles, not only did the industry identify the problem and fight for a legislative solution, but they also brought forward a proven and tested technical solution. It is also worth noting that the SVI technical proposal received no pushback from the vehicle manufacturer development community at SAE, nor in the Massachusetts hearing.

The latest chapter in the Right to Repair saga involves the introduction of federal legislation in the House by U.S. Rep. Bobby Rush (D-Illinois). The Right to Equitable and Professional Auto Industry Repair (REPAIR) Act (HR 6570) “will ensure the preservation of consumer choice, a fair marketplace, and the continued safe operation of the nation’s 288 million registered passenger and commercial motor vehicles, 70% of which are maintained by independent repair facilities,” according to the associations.

The REPAIR act and Rep. Rush deserve the full support of the aftermarket industry. Your elected officials need to hear from you and be urged to co-sponsor this bill. Visit the web site – – to learn more about the Vehicle Data issue and easily send a message to your congressman and senator informing them about how important Right to Repair is to you, their constituent.

In Massachusetts, the aftermarket prevailed against 170 lobbyists hired by the car companies, and the voters saw through the misleading ads of the most expensive automotive media blitz in the history of the state. Winning the Right to Repair once and for all on the federal level will require the energetic support of the 4.4 million people who work every day to keep America rolling.

You May Also Like

Auto Care Association Welcomes GAO Report on Vehicle Repair Restrictions

Auto Care is renewing its call for Congress to advance federal Right to Repair legislation that protects independent business owners and consumers.

Right to repair 2

Following the release of a new Government Accountability Office (GAO) report detailing how automaker restrictions on vehicle data are creating barriers to repair vehicles, the Auto Care Association is renewing its call for Congress to advance federal right to repair legislation that protects independent business owners and consumers.

MEMA Applauds the EPA on Light- and Medium-Duty Vehicle Emission Standards

MEMA says the EPA final rule includes an amended and more comprehensive analysis of technological alternatives.

Opposition Grows for California’s Mandate Banning New Gas-Powered Vehicle Sales
Maryland Teamsters Call for Passage of HB 1447

The legislation would protect middle-class jobs and motorist safety, according to the International Brotherhood of Teamsters.

Maryland Teamsters Call for Passage of HB 1447
$78B Pro-Business Tax Bill Passes House, Awaits Senate

The bill aims to reinstate tax incentives for R&D and small business investments, along with other measures.

MANN+HUMMEL NA Aftermarket Shows Right to Repair Support

Representatives from MANN+HUMMEL’s North American aftermarket brands recently visited Capitol Hill to express their support for H.R. 906.

Other Posts
Majority of Independent Repair Shops View Vehicle Data Access as Top Business Issue

Eighty-four percent of independent repair shops made that claim, surpassing other timely considerations, like technician recruitment and retention and inflation.

Right to repair 2
Commentary: Right to Repair with LKQ’s Ian Musselman

Musselman says passing right to repair legislation is vital – for consumer choice, for independent businesses, for American jobs and for healthy market competition.

Commentary: Right to Repair with LKQ's Ian Musselman
Auto Care Voices Support for FTC, DOJ Comments on Right to Repair

The agencies asserted that renewing and expanding repair-related exemptions would promote competition in markets for replacement parts, repair and maintenance services.

bill hanvey right to repair
MEMA Aftermarket Provides Maine Right to Repair Update

MEMA opposes the Maine legislature advancing a law that would undo major parts of the right-to-repair referendum.

MEMA Aftermarket Recaps Maine Right to Repair Update