“Got Milk?” Promotion Found to be Illegal; Effect on TIA’s Tire Industry Checkoff Program Uncertain - aftermarketNews

“Got Milk?” Promotion Found to be Illegal; Effect on TIA’s Tire Industry Checkoff Program Uncertain

On Feb. 24, a federal appeals court ruled that the familiar “Got Milk?” dairy promotion violates the First Amendment by forcing all farmers to pay for the ads, whether they agree with the ads or not. The 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Philadelphia ruled that federal laws requiring dairy farmers to pay fees to promote the industry infringe “free speech and association rights.” The decision could have serious ramifications for the tire industry, especially with regard to the Tire Industry Association’s (TIA) ongoing support and formal proposal for a tire industry checkoff program.

PHILADELPHIA — On Feb. 24, a federal appeals court ruled that the familiar “Got Milk?” dairy promotion violates the First Amendment by forcing all farmers to pay for the ads, whether they agree with the ads or not.

The 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Philadelphia ruled that federal laws requiring dairy farmers to pay fees to promote the industry infringe “free speech and association rights.”

The decision could have serious ramifications for the tire industry, especially with regard to the Tire Industry Association’s (TIA) ongoing support and formal proposal for a tire industry checkoff program.

Donald Shea, president and CEO of the Rubber Manufacturers Association (RMA), said the decision adds “something concrete” to the RMA’s original concerns of the legal hurdles a checkoff program for the tire industry might present.

“RMA does not support or oppose the checkoff program” said Shea. “We want to raise several issues that must be answered before we can even consider such a program. First, and most important, is dealer support. If there is no dealer support, the whole deck of cards collapses. The second issue is the legal hurdle, and with this most recent decision, now we’ve got something concrete backing it up.”

Shea also added that this most recent court ruling is the third court decision within the last eight months to invalidate a checkoff program. “First was the beef industry decision last July, and the second one was the pork industry this past October. What these three separate decisions do is issue caution to anyone pursuing a checkoff program. Courts have indicated that there are some First Amendment hurdles,” he said.

Shea noted, however, that he needed more details about TIA’s proposed checkoff concept before he could deliver a full assessment of the implications of the court decision.

_______________________________________

Click here to view the rest of today’s headlines.

You May Also Like

Dorman Releases New Chassis Parts, Heater Hoses

New products include a body mount bolt kit for GM pickups and suspension control arms for various vehicle makes.

Dorman-Products-building-HQ

Dorman Products, Inc. has unveiled over 200 new motor vehicle and heavy-duty truck repair solutions this February, catering to automotive and heavy-duty parts distributors, retailers and repair shops, the company said. The latest releases encompass a range of repair solutions, including components like chassis parts and heater hoses, as well as park assist cameras and transmission coolers.

Arnott Releases Over 20 Products in February

Included in the release are air springs, new air struts, new coil-over strut assemblies, new shocks, coil spring conversion kits, air suspension compressors and solenoid valve blocks.

Arnott Releases Over 20 Products in February
CRC Industries Expands Evapo-Rust Line 

A new one-quart canister size for CRC’s Evapo-Rust brand of rust remover hits retail shelves this month.

CRC Industries Expands Evapo-Rust Line 
DMA Industries Announces Expanded BrakeMaster Line

The new release includes 17 brake wear sensors, featuring nine automotive sensors and eight truck sensors.

DMA Industries Announces Expanded BrakeMaster Line
Allison Ventures Makes Strategic Investment in Niron Magnetics

Sustainable non-rare earth permanent magnets for integration in EV propulsion motors and renewable energy systems will be developed.

Allison Ventures Makes Strategic Investment in Niron Magnetics

Other Posts

The Packaging Pickle & Sustainability

While Valvoline Global Operations is working on the molecular make-up of its products, one area of improvement for the company is packaging.

Valvoline-packaging
Philips Introduces New Xperion 3000 LED Work Light Line

The new line includes 10 work lights, nine of which are powered by rechargeable lithium batteries. 

Philips Introduces New Xperion 3000 LED Work Light Line
Cloyes Gear & Products Acquires Automotive Tensioners Inc.

The partnership aims to deliver an improved and cohesive timing system solution to modern automotive repair shops, Cloyes said.

Alltech Automotive Adds Wheel Hubs to QualityPro Brand

The QualityPro wheel hubs feature an e-coating treatment aimed at enhancing corrosion resistance in an environmentally friendly way.

Quality-Pro-wheel-hubs