Supreme Court Agrees To Hear Case Seeking To Overturn Prohibition On Sales Tax Collection For Online Purchases

Supreme Court Agrees To Hear Case Seeking To Overturn Prohibition On Sales Tax Collection For Online Purchases

The practice of “showrooming,” where consumers check out products in stores and then purchase the product over the internet due to lower prices, was highlighted as an ongoing concern.

The United States Supreme Court has decided to hear a case brought by the state of South Dakota seeking to overturn the 1992 Quill v. North Dakota decision that has prevented states from collecting sales tax on purchases made over the internet. The petition, filed by the attorney general for South Dakota, had requested that the U.S. Supreme Court review a state Supreme Court decision, which denied the state the ability to enforce a 2016 law passed in South Dakota that required state sales tax be collected on all internet sales.

The Auto Care Association had joined nine other trade associations in signing an amicus brief, which supported the South Dakota petition. The brief had echoed the petitioner’s request that the court overturn the 1992 decision, citing the real-world impacts on brick-and-mortar businesses due to the competitive disadvantage brought on by having to charge sales tax while online competition does not. The practice of “showrooming,” where consumers check out products in stores and then purchase the product over the internet due to lower prices, was highlighted as an ongoing concern. The brief further cited the significant investment in employee training and showroom displays, taken advantage of by the consumer prior to them choosing to buy online.

“The Auto Care Association is pleased that the court has taken this important step and we stand ready to assist petitioners in demonstrating to the court why it is critical that the Quill decision be overturned such that fairness can be returned to the marketplace,” said Aaron Lowe, senior vice president, regulatory and government affairs, Auto Care Association.

You May Also Like

Automakers Ask for More Time in MA Right to Repair Trial

Meanwhile, in Washington, D.C., the Committee on Small Business Subcommittee on Underserved, Agricultural, and Rural Business Development will hold a hearing on Right to Repair at 10 a.m. EST on Wed., Sept. 14. 

The status of Massachusetts’ Right to Repair legislation continues to meet delays as a coalition of automakers seeks to overturn the new law approved by a majority of Massachusetts voters in November 2020. 

Approved by an overwhelming 75-25 percent margin in 2020, the new Right to Repair law would require manufacturers to provide vehicle owners both access and control of the diagnostic and repair data generated by their vehicles. Subsequent to the vote, the car company trade group, Alliance for Automotive Innovation filed a lawsuit (Alliance for Automotive Innovation vs. Maura Healey, Attorney General of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts) in November 2020 asking the court to overturn the data access ballot question based on a host of allegations including cybersecurity concerns, insufficient time to comply with the new data access requirements and their contention that the ballot initiative is preempted by federal law. The court case has seen numerous delays over the past two years. 

NHRA Champ Brown Warns Congress: Motorsports Is At Risk

Antron Brown shared inspiring stories about the value of racing, and why he is pushing for passage of the RPM Act.

T/CCI Manufacturing Awarded ‘REV Illinois’ Tax Incentive

T/CCI’s additional $20M investment will establish an EV innovation hub including a groundbreaking climatic center for innovation and research.

NHRA Top Fuel Champion To Testify in Senate Hearing

Antron Brown will testify on behalf of passage of the Recognizing the Protection of Motorsports (RPM) Act.

Study: National EV Adoption will be Gradual

The Energy Innovation study modeled the effect of tax credits based on a low, moderate and high scenario.

Other Posts

Maine Auto Repair Shops Pursue Right-To-Repair Referendum

The repair shops say the industry’s grip on newer, advanced technology threatens consumers’ right to choose.

T/CCI Attends White House CHIPS and Science Bill Signing

The $280B legislation will further innovation and research in manufacturing.

Automotive Youtuber Rich Rebuilds Promotes Car Coalition

The YouTuber urges his 1.3 million subscribers to learn more about both SMART and the REPAIR Acts.

US Automakers Urge Passage of Semiconductor Funding

Automakers are urging the Biden Administration and congressional leaders to finalize legislation that will include $52 billion in incentives.