Guest Commentary: Vehicle Inspection Impact

Guest Commentary: Vehicle Inspection Impact

The greatest enemy of vehicle inspections also is its greatest advocate, the elected official.

Editor’s Note: In August, aftermarketNews published an opinion piece by Andrew Markel regarding his thoughts on state vehicle inspections. You can read that first column here. He follows up on those thoughts below.

In August, I wrote my column on vehicle inspection programs that attacked some of the “technical” shortcomings of some safety and emissions programs. Let me be clear – even with these deficiencies, many of these programs have had a substantial impact on public safety and our environment.   

Currently, 19 states have periodic safety vehicle inspections, 32 states have regular emissions inspections and only 12 states have no form of vehicle inspection.

The greatest enemy of vehicle inspections also is its greatest advocate, the elected official. Some politicians see the elimination of vehicle inspections as a win for the annual budget and their constituents. Some even say they are putting money back into the pockets of residents, improving the local economy. What they forget is that local repair shops are locally owned and put a lot back into the local economy as well, by creating jobs and purchasing from local brick and mortar parts stores.

Texas tried to eliminate vehicle safety inspections in 2018. In defense of the program, the Texas Department of Safety commissioned a survey to demonstrate the value of vehicle inspections. 

Here are some of the findings of the study:

• Crashes involving vehicles with defects are twice as likely to result in a fatality.

• The most prevalent type of defect related to fatal crashes is slick or defective tires.

• Inspection station owners would lose a net revenue of more than $131 million per year.

• Vehicle owners would save $307 million per year.

Any elected official or voter should be hesitant to eliminate a program that has these social and economic benefits. But some states are actively easing or eliminating their vehicle inspection programs. Last month, Missouri limited inspections to vehicles with 150,000 miles or older than five years. Oregon is looking at increasing inspections on medium-duty trucks and using the inspection fees to purchase vehicle charging stations. Politicians need to hear from shop owners about the value of these programs.

Whether it’s 1930 or 2019, vehicle inspection programs have remained controversial. Why? It is difficult to measure a crash or pollution that never happens. What people see is the price they have to pay if they fail an inspection.

The one thing people forget is that inspections often spot issues before they become more expensive problems. Even in the case of emissions-only inspections, a car with a code is likely doing damage to the engine and catalytic converters.

You May Also Like

Time to Hit the Road

Outgoing AMN Editor Amy Antenora reflects on her time covering the automotive aftermarket.

Amy Antenora aftermarket news

Twenty years. That’s more than 5,000 business days, roughly 15 AAPEX shows (for me, at least), more than 400 executive interviews and who knows how many article posts.

That’s what my time here at Babcox Media, as Editor of aftermarketNews, looks like in black and white numbers. But that’s not the real measure of what I’ve accumulated over 20 years’ time.

‘The Aftermarket Should Not Fear the Future’

Paul McCarthy flipped the script on vehicle technology and its potential impact on the automotive aftermarket.

The Challenge of Organizational Culture, Post-Covid

The impact of Covid on our society and organizations will not be fully understood for many years.

Four Keys to Creating a Succession Plan That Works

Do you have a plan in place to ensure your business maintains its success after you leave?

Commentary: The Power of Team Spirit

Dr. John A Passante & Dr. Thomas Litzinger share their thoughts on the multiplying benefits of adopting a team spirit.

Other Posts

As Cars Keep Aging, What Will The Future Look Like?

The big issue for the next 22 years is how sensors and software that make driving safer impact vehicle serviceability.

Parts and Artificial Intelligence

In the past 25 years, things have changed with the Internet.

The Mission of Leadership is to Build a Learning Organization

Does your organization make space and time for groundbreaking ideas, innovation and inspiration?

Business Remains a Shared Experience

Relationships, facts, clear consistent communication and guidance are critical touchpoints with employees and customers.